CAD similarity search: find similar components for the calculation

State:
AI-generated

Similarity of form and production context

How geometric similarity is measured

Two components are geometrically similar if their shape is similar to the characteristics that count for the respective question. There are three approaches to this with increasing effort.

Characteristic values are easiest: envelope dimensions, volume, surface and their ratios can be calculated from any volume model. They find parts of a similar size and shape, but they do not distinguish between a shaft and an equally large block with holes.

Features go one step further. Recognized holes, pockets, grooves and turning diameters describe how a part is made, and are closer to the calculation. Their quality depends on the model quality; simplified models without holes or threads distort the feature counting.

Form-based methods calculate a kind of fingerprint from the entire geometry and compare these fingerprints with each other. They also find parts that are differently named or differently structured, but do not say anything about material, tolerances or quantity. For the calculation, such a result is therefore always only the first filter.

Finding similarity in construction and calculation

Construction Calculation
Objective reuse existing parts, avoid double constructions Use times, work sequence and costs of a known part as a starting point
Criteria Shape, dimensions, function, standard parts Shape and dimensions plus material, process, machine, quantity, tolerances, surfaces
Result an existing part instead of a new construction a reference proposal with visible differences to the new request
Risk hardly, the part is already released old assumptions or outdated cost rates are updated unchecked

The same search technique serves two different purposes. In the calculation, the production context decides whether a form-like part is suitable as a reference at all.

Reference suggestions in your own working environment

In the own working environment for manufacturing companies, CNC Kalkulator proposes a reference part according to fixed rules for a calculation. A candidate must be in the same working area and have the same process, the same material and the same machine. Each finished dimension may not differ more than 25 percent, the quantity at most by a factor of two. Confirmed references are available before unconfirmed, because only confirmed actual times can be transferred into a calculation.

For each proposal, the calculation shows the basis for comparison: the deviation of each measure in percent, the quantity ratio and the applicable limits. Thus, it is recognizable why a part is considered similar. A reference is only taken over when it has been explicitly selected.

Reference as proposal, release by humans

A found reference shortens the calculation, because work sequence, machine and documented assumptions do not need to be recollected. However, it does not replace the test of the new request: a deeper bag, an additional cross hole, narrower tolerances or a different batch size change setup, processing and testing effort. The old calculation remains unchanged, the new one is created as its own stand and remains recognizable which value comes from the reference.

How reference parts are searched and compared in the product is shown in the page Reference parts and previous calculations, the sequence of a specific request of the application case Deriving offer from a similar reference part. The information taken from the model and drawing describes the page for the CAD data transfer.

Key points

Similarity is explained in such a way that inputs, procedures, effects and limits in the CNC calculation remain comprehensible.

  • Connect form and context: Geometric resemblance becomes a useful reference only with material, process, machine and batch size.
  • Make differences visible: Dimensions, quantity and requirements are compared before something is taken over.
  • Releasing remains with the human: A reference is a suggestion; it is only accepted after conscious selection.

Questions and answers

The most important practical questions on similarity and the classification into a reliable calculation.

What functions do you need to compare similar parts?

A search for geometry and production context, i.e. dimensions and characteristics together with material, processes, machine and quantity; a comparison that shows deviations per criterion; a distinction between confirmed and unconfirmed references; a comprehensible origin of each value taken over and an explicit selection by humans before data goes into a new calculation.

How to measure geometric similarity of CAD components?

Simply over characteristic values such as envelope dimensions, volume and surface, more precisely over recognized features such as holes, pockets and turning diameters, and most comprehensive over form-based methods, which calculate and compare from the geometry a kind of fingerprint. Each method finds different hits; for the calculation form-likeness alone is not enough.

Can I take over the price of a similar part?

A narrower tolerance, an additional tension, another semi-finished product or a different quantity can have more influence on time and costs than the optical similarity. The reference provides work sequences, assumptions and actual times as the starting point; the new calculation is independently tested.

What does the construction use a search for resemblance?

In particular, to avoid double constructions and to reuse existing parts. However, the calculation searches for references with the same production context to transfer times and costs.

Pro tools in the CNC Calculator app

Offer management with process line, variants, cost changes and approvals; Pro is activated on request. Pro is available and will be unlocked on request; the price will be indicated on request.

Pro tools in CNC Kalkulator
View Pro Tools in the App

Pro on request · free tools available immediately

Questions about similarity in your own calculation we gladly clarify personally: Book free first interview.

Carlo D'Este
D'Este Solutions

Welcome to the CNC Calculator

We will be happy to help you with any questions regarding the app, pro or your calculation.

Questions? Call us!