Self-production or external reference: calculate cost comparison

State:
AI-generated

Same scope of delivery on both sides

Drawing revision, material, quantity, inspection, documentation, packaging and delivery location must match. The supplier's price may include transport, receipt of goods, inspection and additional support. A pure part price is then not yet a complete third party purchase price.

Material, processing and one-off costs related to the order are used for self-production. Existing fixed costs do not disappear automatically when purchased by third parties. For a short-term decision, it is therefore necessary to clarify which costs can actually be avoided.

Calculate Critical Quantity

If the self-production has higher fixed costs, but lower variable unit costs, there is a cutting quantity in the linear model. Below this can be cheaper for third parties, above self-production. Same variable costs or unfavourable differences can lead to no positive cutting quantity.

N_critical = (fix costs_own − fixed costs_foreign) ו (unit costs_foreign − unit costs_own)

Sample calculation with 300 pieces as cutting quantity

Accepted self-production: 1,200 € One-time expenses plus 8 € per piece. Accepted external purchase: 300 € Order-related purchase costs plus 11 € per piece. The difference is 900 € fixed and 3 € variable costs; the cutting amount is 300 pieces.

For 100 pieces, self-production costs 2,000 € and third party purchase 1,400 €. For 500 pieces, it is 5,200 € and 5,800 €. These are calculation values, no offers or market prices.

Complement capacity and risk

A cost-effective self-production can fail due to lack of capacity, equipment or release. Conversely, minimum quantity, delivery time, supplier risk and necessary rework influence the external purchase. These points are documented in addition to the cost result, instead of being concealed by a flat-rate unknown surcharge.

Questions and answers

Is the critical amount an automatic purchase decision?

No. It applies to the linear costs entered. Availability, quality, dates, quantity scales and avoidable costs can change the decision.

Which fixed costs are allowed in the comparison?

For a concrete decision, the costs caused or avoided by the variant in question may be different. For a long-term full cost assessment, the demarcation may be different; the chosen view must be the same on both sides.

In-house production or purchase in the CNC calculator app

Compares decision-relevant self-production costs with a binding purchase price.

Compare your own production or purchase free of charge in the CNC Kalkulator with input and result
Calculate in the app

Free tools in your browser without sign-in

How the calculation from drawing, CAD model and your operating data looks like with you, we will gladly clarify on one of your parts: Book free first interview.

Carlo D'Este
D'Este Solutions

Welcome to the CNC Calculator

We will be happy to help you with any questions regarding the app, pro or your calculation.

Questions? Call us!