Calculate deflection: tool and workpiece under cutting force

AI-generated

For a cantilever, f = F × L³ ÷ (3 × E × I), for a beam between two supports, f = F × L³ ÷ (48 × E × I). Because the length is in the third power, double cantilever increases the bending moment.

Formulas

f = F × L³ ÷ (3 × E × I)

Single-sided

Tool elongation, drill rod, freestanding workpiece end.

f = F × L³ ÷ (48 × E × I)

Two conditions, central force

Wave between feed and tailstock.

I = π × d⁴ ÷ 64

Round cross-section

The diameter is in the fourth potency.

I = b × h³ ÷ 12

Rectangular cross section

The height in force direction is crucial.

Steel shaft Ø 20 mm, 120 mm free, 400 N cutting force

Single-sided clamped, E = 210,000 N/mm², permissible 0.05 mm.

  1. Area moment of inertia I = π × 20⁴ ÷ 647,854 mm4
  2. Bending moment = 400 × 120³ ÷ (3 × 210,000 × 7,854)0,140 mm
  3. Ratio to the specification of 0,05 mm279 %
  4. Maximum free length for 0.05 mm85.2 mm
  5. Permissible force at 120 mm length143 N

ResultAt 0.140 mm, the deflection is almost three times higher than the target.

To hold 0.05 mm, the free length shall be only 85 mm or the cutting force shall not exceed 143 N. A solid carbide shaft would be a third possibility: with a triple E module, the deflection would remain at around 0.05 mm.

Rigidity decides on the size and surface

Deflection creates dimensional deviation, poor surface and ratters. Those who estimate it before the offer, can recognize at an early stage whether a component needs additional support, smaller cutting values or more finishing gears.

Questions and answers

How to calculate the deflection?

For a single-sidedly stressed tool, f = F × L³ ÷ (3 × E × I), for a beam supported on both sides with central force f = F × L³ ÷ (48 × E × I). E is the modulus of elasticity, I is the moment of inertia of the cross-section.

What is the moment of inertia?

It describes how strongly a cross-section of a beam resists bending. For a circle, I = π × d⁴ ÷ 64, for a rectangle I = b × h³ ÷ 12. Because the diameter is raised to the fourth power, it is the most effective lever.

Why is it so critical?

Because the length is cubic. Double elongation means eight times deflection with the same force. Therefore, a shorter tool holder often brings more than a more expensive tool.

What difference does carbide make over steel?

With around 600,000 N/mm², solid carbide has the triple modulus of elasticity of steel. With the same geometry, a VHM shaft bends only about one third – this is the main reason for VHM extensions in deep cavities.

How is that related to ratters?

Static deflection is an indicator of low stiffness, and low stiffness lowers the natural frequency. It does not replace stability analysis, but is a good early warning value: Whoever is above the permissible deflection usually also has a rat problem.

Tool deflection in the CNC Calculator app

Calculates elastic deflection of a single-sided clamping circular tool under transverse force.

Free calculator for tool deflection in CNC Kalkulator with input and result
Calculate in the app

Free tools in your browser without sign-in

How "Tool deflection" with geometry, drawing requirements and your cost rates becomes an offer, we are happy to clarify personally: Book free first interview.

Carlo D'Este
D'Este Solutions

Welcome to the CNC Calculator

We will be happy to help you with any questions regarding the app, pro or your calculation.

Questions? Call us!