Choose threaded, threaded or threaded mills correctly

State:
AI-generated

Threading process by material, component value and batch size

Three methods for an internal thread

An internal thread can be drilled, molded or milled. All three methods create the same thread profile, but differ in how the material is removed or displaced, which core hole they need and what happens when the tool fails.

Thread drilling cuts the thread with a tool whose profile corresponds to the thread. The feed is determined by the slope (vf = n × P), a thread is created in a back and forth way. This is fast and requires little programming effort. However, the thread drill works form-bound and can break in the bore, especially in bagholes with poor chip removal and tough materials.

Thread moulds replaces the material instead of cutting it. No chips are created, the thread is solidified, and the process is very stable with suitable materials. For this, the mould needs a larger core hole, which must be more accurate than when cutting, a sufficiently ductile material and a higher torque on the spindle.

Thread milling creates the thread on a helix web with a cutter that is smaller than the thread. The feed is freely selectable and is converted to the center of the tool with the circle correction. The measure can be adjusted via the radius correction, a milling cutter covers several diameters of the same slope, and breaks it rarely, remains stuck in the component. Milling usually takes longer per thread, and an NC program with helix and starting motion is necessary.

Selection by material, bore and component

Criterion Threaded drilling Threading Threading machines
Material most machinable materials only sufficiently ductile materials also difficult to machine and brittle materials
Chips yes, rejection critical in the baghole none Yes, short chips
Corehole Drill diameter according to DIN 336 larger, according to the shaper data sheet as when cutting
Time per thread Short Short Longer
Result of a tool break Tool is often in the component Tool is often in the component Miller rare in the component
Measurement correction No, measure by tool No, measure by tool yes, about the radius correction

The table describes trends. The data of the tool manufacturer and the own experience are determined by which tool actually runs process-proof in which material.

What the choice means for the calculation

For the calculation, the complete chain per thread counts: centering or drilling, core hole drilling, sinking, threading and deburring, each with tool change and positioning distance. For a component with twenty threads, this quickly results in more minutes than for the entire contour processing, although the removed volume is minimal. A pure volume estimate therefore systematically leads to low volume estimates for well-rich components.

The process shifts the weights. Thread drilling keeps the time small, but bears the risk of losing an almost finished part by a broken thread drill; this risk belongs in the process decision, not in a lump sum. Thread milling costs more time per thread, but saves tool variety on rare gradients and reduces the reject risk on expensive parts. Thread shapes saves chips, but requires the right material and an exact core hole.

The core holes per thread size are on the side Calculating core hole, incline and voltage cross section in the Thread table M3 to M24. Speed and corrected web feed for milling calculate the side Thread milling.

Key points

Threads are explained in such a way that inputs, procedures, effects and limits in the CNC calculation remain comprehensible.

  • Material first: Moulds need a ductile material; brittle and hard-to-machine materials are more likely to speak for milling.
  • Construction value: The more expensive the part is when threading, the more process reliability counts over seconds.
  • Calculate whole chain: Centering, core hole, sinking, threading and deburring are part of every thread.

Questions and answers

The most important practical questions about threads and the classification into a reliable calculation.

When is threading better than threading?

If the material is sufficiently ductile, such as many steels, aluminium and copper alloys, and chips in the bag hole would interfere. The shaped thread is created by displacing and has no chips; however, a larger core hole is needed, which is drilled according to the data sheet of the former. Forms are unsuitable in brittle materials such as grey cast iron.

When is thread milling worth it?

For large or expensive components, hard-to-machine materials, large diameters, bagholes with a tight thread outlet and rare gradients. A milling cutter covers several diameters of the same slope, the dimension can be adjusted via radius correction, and a broken milling cutter rarely remains stuck in the component.

Which method is fastest in the series?

For small and medium threads, the threading or threading is usually done because the thread is created in a back and forth path and the feed is fixed through the slope (vf = n × P). Thread milling, on the other hand, requires at least one rotation on the helix, and for single profile milling machines one per slope.

Where can I find the core hole per thread size?

Calculate core hole on the page: There the core holes M3 to M24 stand for cutting according to DIN 336 and the guide value for forming in a table, plus speed and feed of the threaded drill. The thread table shows the slope, flank diameter and stress cross-section per size.

How much carrying depth does a thread need?

Between 60 and 75 per cent of load-bearing depth, almost the full extraction strength is achieved. More load-bearing depth increases cutting torque and breakage risk of the threaded drill without making the connection significantly firmer.

Core hole diameter in the CNC Calculator app

Calculates the core hole direction value for cut and shaped metric threads.

Free core hole calculator in CNC Kalkulator with input and result
Calculate in the app

Free tools in your browser without sign-in

Questions about threads in your own calculation we will gladly clarify personally: Book free first interview.

Carlo D'Este
D'Este Solutions

Welcome to the CNC Calculator

We will be happy to help you with any questions regarding the app, pro or your calculation.

Questions? Call us!